January 27, 2024

Is AC or DC better for long distance transmission?

AC (alternating current) is generally preferred for long-distance transmission of electricity. There are several reasons for this:

  1. Lower Transmission Losses: AC can be transmitted at high voltages using transformers to step up the voltage before transmission and step it down at the destination. This allows for long-distance transmission with lower losses compared to DC.
  2. Ease of Voltage Conversion: AC can be easily converted to different voltage levels using transformers, which makes it suitable for long-distance transmission where voltage needs to be stepped up for reduced losses and then stepped down for safe distribution.
  3. Historical Infrastructure: The existing electricity grid infrastructure is predominantly based on AC transmission lines. Converting existing infrastructure to DC transmission would require significant investment and overhaul.
  4. Fault Clearance: AC systems tend to have better mechanisms for clearing faults (such as short circuits) compared to DC systems, which enhances the reliability of AC transmission networks.

While DC transmission has advantages in certain scenarios, such as underwater cables or specific point-to-point transmission over very long distances, AC remains the dominant choice for long-distance transmission due to its overall efficiency, reliability, and existing infrastructure.

Cross-section of a car gearbox. mechanic work in the garage Cross-section of a car gearbox. mechanic work in the garage. car transmission stock pictures, royalty-free photos & images

Which is best for long distance power transmission?

For long-distance power transmission, alternating current (AC) is typically considered the best option overall. Here’s why:
  1. Lower Transmission Losses: AC can be transmitted at high voltages, which reduces resistive losses along transmission lines. By stepping up the voltage using transformers, the current can be decreased, resulting in lower power losses according to the formula P = I^2 * R.
  2. Voltage Regulation: AC systems allow for easier voltage regulation through the use of transformers, ensuring that the voltage remains within acceptable limits throughout the transmission network.
  3. Existing Infrastructure: The vast majority of the world’s electricity grid infrastructure is based on AC transmission. Utilizing AC for long-distance transmission leverages this existing infrastructure, reducing the need for costly upgrades or replacements.
  4. Efficient Power Grid Operation: AC systems allow for the interconnected operation of multiple generators and loads, providing flexibility and reliability in the power grid operation.
  5. Fault Management: AC systems typically have better fault management capabilities compared to direct current (DC) systems. AC networks are designed with protective devices and mechanisms that can quickly isolate and clear faults, minimizing disruptions to the power supply.

While direct current (DC) transmission has certain advantages, such as lower losses over extremely long distances or for specific applications like underwater cables, AC remains the preferred choice for long-distance power transmission due to its overall efficiency, reliability, and compatibility with existing infrastructure.